WEATHER ALERT
Hundreds of troops expected to arrive in Big Bend region for border security mission, report says
Read full article: Hundreds of troops expected to arrive in Big Bend region for border security mission, report saysMilitary presence along the U.S.-Mexico border is expected to grow in the next few weeks as part of a border security mission, according to a report from Marfa Public Radio.
โItโs tragicโ: Officials seek answers after vandalism of Quintana Road memorial honoring 53 migrants
Read full article: โItโs tragicโ: Officials seek answers after vandalism of Quintana Road memorial honoring 53 migrantsOfficials are seeking answers after a memorial honoring the 53 migrants who were killed in a 2022 smuggling tragedy along Quintana Road was vandalized.
Trump administration drops challenge to Texas law targeting people who illegally cross the border
Read full article: Trump administration drops challenge to Texas law targeting people who illegally cross the borderSenate Bill 4, the Texas law that makes illegally crossing the border a state crime, will continue to be challenged by two immigrant rights groups and El Paso County.
Feds are opening more detention centers in Texas as Trump administration steps up deportations
Read full article: Feds are opening more detention centers in Texas as Trump administration steps up deportationsThe feds are adding thousands of beds to hold families in Texas, which reportedly holds the most immigrants of any state at its 21 detention centers.
FEMA wants the names and addresses of migrants helped by Texas nonprofits and local governments that got federal grant money
Read full article: FEMA wants the names and addresses of migrants helped by Texas nonprofits and local governments that got federal grant moneyA letter sent this week claims the grant recipients, including many Texas cities and counties, may have illegally โinducedโ undocumented immigrants to enter the country.
Paxton investigates Dallas for alleged sanctuary city policies
Read full article: Paxton investigates Dallas for alleged sanctuary city policiesAttorney General Ken Paxton said a recent statement by Dallasโ interim police chief raised concerns that the city might be violating a state law against so-called sanctuary city policies.
How state lawmakers are trying to crack down on illegal immigration
Read full article: How state lawmakers are trying to crack down on illegal immigrationFrom requiring law enforcement agencies to cooperate with federal officials to forcing state contractors to use E-Verify to spot undocumented workers, here are the bills that could reshape the stateโs immigration policies.
Venezuelan parents watch from home as their son is buried in Texas after drowning
Read full article: Venezuelan parents watch from home as their son is buried in Texas after drowningGustavo Alfonso Garcia Olivares died at 24, drowning in the Rio Grande not far from where he was buried Thursday at the Maverick County Cemetery in Eagle Pass.
Federal judge won't order immigration officials to change school arrests policy
Read full article: Federal judge won't order immigration officials to change school arrests policyA federal judge says he won't order immigration authorities to revert to a Biden-era policy limiting arrests at schools after officials in Denver challenged new policies from the Trump administration.
KSAT joins ICE San Antonio for exclusive ride-along amid intensified immigration enforcement
Read full article: KSAT joins ICE San Antonio for exclusive ride-along amid intensified immigration enforcementTwo and a half months into President Donald Trumpโs second term and the administration continues to crack down on illegal immigration.
South Texas immigration detention center with capacity for 2,400 people to reopen
Read full article: South Texas immigration detention center with capacity for 2,400 people to reopenThe Biden administration shuttered the Dilley facility last year because of high operating costs. Itโs expected to hold immigrant families under the Trump administration.
TIMELINE: Developments in 2022 San Antonio migrant smuggling tragedy that left 53 dead
Read full article: TIMELINE: Developments in 2022 San Antonio migrant smuggling tragedy that left 53 deadOn June 27, 2022, 53 people were killed in a semitrailer smuggling incident that San Antonio Police Chief William McManus called the largest mass casualty event in San Antonio that he could remember.
Operaciones de ICE en Texas: Quรฉ derechos tienen los inmigrantes
Read full article: Operaciones de ICE en Texas: Quรฉ derechos tienen los inmigrantesAbogados y grupos de inmigraciรณn recomiendan a los inmigrantes informarse sobre las acciones de la administraciรณn del presidente Donald Trump, como la expansiรณn del uso de expulsiones aceleradas.
How the Supreme Court of the United States and federal courts work and affect Texans
Read full article: How the Supreme Court of the United States and federal courts work and affect TexansHereโs how federal courts help determine the fate of controversial issues, such as immigration laws, in Texas and beyond.
Daughter of 81-year-old man allegedly murdered by significant other calls for accountability
Read full article: Daughter of 81-year-old man allegedly murdered by significant other calls for accountabilityItโs been nearly a month, but Donald Weynandtโs death is still a nightmare for his daughter, Katrina Mercado.
Feds target โcriminals and illegal immigrantsโ in Houston-area development, Abbott says
Read full article: Feds target โcriminals and illegal immigrantsโ in Houston-area development, Abbott saysThe Colony Ridge development has long been under scrutiny from conservative lawmakers, think tanks and influencers who cast it as a hotbed for undocumented immigrants and cartel crime.
In Odessa, multiple efforts are underway to help immigrants stay and work
Read full article: In Odessa, multiple efforts are underway to help immigrants stay and workA naturalized citizen, along with other business leaders, are working to create new resources for undocumented people living in the Permian Basin.
Man records video of DPS stop outside elementary school, urges women not to sign anything
Read full article: Man records video of DPS stop outside elementary school, urges women not to sign anythingA man recorded video from a two-hour Texas Department of Safety traffic stop outside an elementary school, which then led to a call for immigration enforcement officials.
โYou can live without fearโ: local leaders host immigration town hall to address community concerns
Read full article: โYou can live without fearโ: local leaders host immigration town hall to address community concernsLocal officials and religious leaders came together Monday evening for an immigration town hall aimed at informing the public and reducing fear in the community.
San Antonioโs Migrant Resource Center closes after last group of migrants leave
Read full article: San Antonioโs Migrant Resource Center closes after last group of migrants leaveThe last group of migrants has departed from San Antonioโs Migrant Resource Center, marking the end of the facilityโs operations.
Texas migrant shelters are nearly empty after Trumpโs actions effectively shut the border
Read full article: Texas migrant shelters are nearly empty after Trumpโs actions effectively shut the borderThe shelters began seeing fewer people dropped off by customs and border agents following former President Joe Bidenโs executive order limiting some asylum claims.
Texas could sell 100 miles of border to feds, Abbott says
Read full article: Texas could sell 100 miles of border to feds, Abbott saysAbbott is in Washington this week to lobby Congress for $11 billion to compensate Texas for money spent on his Operation Lone Star, to secure the border during the Biden Administration.
Texas appeals court hears attorney generalโs arguments for questioning Catholic Charities director over migrant services
Read full article: Texas appeals court hears attorney generalโs arguments for questioning Catholic Charities director over migrant servicesThree Republican judges heard oral arguments Wednesday after a lower court blocked Attorney General Ken Paxtonโs efforts to depose the charityโs leader.
Rep. Roger Williams introduces bill to reimburse Texas for Operation Lone Star
Read full article: Rep. Roger Williams introduces bill to reimburse Texas for Operation Lone StarThe new bill reinforces Gov. Greg Abbottโs push for the federal government to repay the $11 billion Texas has paid for the border security operation.
US military ramps up security presence along Mexico border with spy planes
Read full article: US military ramps up security presence along Mexico border with spy planesThe U.S. military has significantly increased its presence over the Mexican border, conducting a series of missions aimed at monitoring drug cartels and enhancing border security.
โKnow Your Rightsโ rally unites community in protest of immigration polices, deportations
Read full article: โKnow Your Rightsโ rally unites community in protest of immigration polices, deportationsA โKnow Your Rightsโ rally took place in Milam Park on Saturday in opposition to President Donald Trumpโs handling of border security and his rhetoric on immigration and deportations.
South San Antonio High School students protest Trumpโs immigration efforts with on-campus walkout
Read full article: South San Antonio High School students protest Trumpโs immigration efforts with on-campus walkoutNearly 1,000 South San Antonio High School students walked out of class on Friday to protest President Donald Trumpโs immigration efforts.
Local nonprofit immigration services provider warns of scams targeting migrants
Read full article: Local nonprofit immigration services provider warns of scams targeting migrantsJesus Romero started the Educational and Legal Immigration Ministries (ELIM) in 2003 as a way to protect migrants from falling victim to people who were trying to take advantage of their fear and desperation.
Border Patrol chief calls report that agents will board buses to check studentsโ citizenship โabsurdโ
Read full article: Border Patrol chief calls report that agents will board buses to check studentsโ citizenship โabsurdโThe chiefโs comments came after Alice ISD sent a letter to parents Wednesday warning students may be detained and possibly deported if they canโt prove theyโre in the country legally. The letter was later removed from the districtโs website.
U.S. can have our wall, bases and detention cells, Abbott tells Trump
Read full article: U.S. can have our wall, bases and detention cells, Abbott tells TrumpThe governor said the state resources are available to the federal government and requested that the U.S. reimburse Texas for the border hardening measures under Operation Lone Star.
After teasing border security rollback, Texas plunges in deeper
Read full article: After teasing border security rollback, Texas plunges in deeperTexasโ border spending exploded after Joe Bidenโs election, then state leaders signaled a new willingness to reduce it when Trump won. That didnโt last long.
Justice Department restarts legal aid programs for detained immigrants
Read full article: Justice Department restarts legal aid programs for detained immigrantsThe agencyโs reversal comes after a federal judge told the Trump administration it must continue to pay for grants and other programs it abruptly froze last month.
Neighbors express relief over impending closure of Migrant Resource Center
Read full article: Neighbors express relief over impending closure of Migrant Resource CenterThe news announced Monday morning about the impending closure of San Antonioโs Migrant Resource Center is coming as a relief to at least one woman who lives nearby.
Immigration crackdown in Texas: What you need to know about your rights
Read full article: Immigration crackdown in Texas: What you need to know about your rightsRecent enforcement operations across Texas have raised concerns among undocumented immigrants. Hereโs what immigration attorneys want you to know about your rights and resources.
โA lot of fear going onโ: Texas immigrant community on edge during Trumpโs first weeks
Read full article: โA lot of fear going onโ: Texas immigrant community on edge during Trumpโs first weeksAcross the state, immigrants and their loved ones are changing their daily habits as the Trump administration orders at least 1,200 daily arrests of undocumented people.
Abbott expected to promote vouchers and other highlights of his 2025 agenda in Sunday speech
Read full article: Abbott expected to promote vouchers and other highlights of his 2025 agenda in Sunday speechAfter successful campaigns for House allies, the governor is in a position to set an ambitious course for the legislative session.
How will San Antonio school districts handle ICE or CBP on campus?
Read full article: How will San Antonio school districts handle ICE or CBP on campus?Some parents are raising concerns about the safety of undocumented students in schools after the Trump administrationโs executive order that has allowed federal agents access to school campuses.
Oklahoma education board members vote to police migrant children, raising questions about potential Texas impact
Read full article: Oklahoma education board members vote to police migrant children, raising questions about potential Texas impactAs Oklahoma education board members move to police the immigration status of students, questions arise about whether similar measures could be implemented in Texas.
KSAT Q&A: Bexar County Sheriff Salazar says his deputies havenโt been โaskedโ to assist in any ICE raids
Read full article: KSAT Q&A: Bexar County Sheriff Salazar says his deputies havenโt been โaskedโ to assist in any ICE raidsBexar County Sheriff Javier Salazar joined KSAT 12 News anchors Steve Spriester and Myra Arthur from Washington D.C. for a KSAT Q&A during Wednesday nightโs 6 OโClock News.
An immigrant faces deportation after a routine traffic stop in Texas, sparking more fear
Read full article: An immigrant faces deportation after a routine traffic stop in Texas, sparking more fearAdvocates worry that rapidly shifting federal and state immigration initiatives will prompt more city police to funnel migrants without criminal records to federal agents.
Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick outlines sweeping conservative agenda with list of top 25 legislative priorities
Read full article: Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick outlines sweeping conservative agenda with list of top 25 legislative prioritiesRestrict THC, help with deportations, infuse religion in schools and provide property tax relief โ these are among the Patrick priorities.
US warns against travel to certain areas of Texas-Mexico border due to gun battles
Read full article: US warns against travel to certain areas of Texas-Mexico border due to gun battlesThe U.S. government is asking people to avoid traveling to certain areas of the Texas-Mexico border due to security concerns.
Department of Justice cuts off federally funded legal aid to detained immigrants
Read full article: Department of Justice cuts off federally funded legal aid to detained immigrantsThe decision to halt the program could prevent thousands of people detained in immigration detention centers from receiving legal advice.
SAISD educator under investigation for alleged support of ICE raids on TikTok
Read full article: SAISD educator under investigation for alleged support of ICE raids on TikTokAn educator at Lorenzo De Zavala Elementary School is facing criticism for making a social media post that called for U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement to raid San Antonio.
Texas Republicans in Congress propose bills to codify Trump executive orders
Read full article: Texas Republicans in Congress propose bills to codify Trump executive ordersEnding birthright citizenship, increasing oil drilling, and leaving WHO are just a few bills the stateโs Republicans pushed in Congress this month.
Abbott sends state troops to U.S.-Mexico border to work with Border Patrol
Read full article: Abbott sends state troops to U.S.-Mexico border to work with Border PatrolThe 400 members of a special tactical unit left bases in Houston and Fort Worth on Monday morning, according to the governorโs office.
Gov. Greg Abbott announces deployment of Texas DPS troopers, special agents to assist federal immigration efforts
Read full article: Gov. Greg Abbott announces deployment of Texas DPS troopers, special agents to assist federal immigration effortsGovernor Greg Abbott announced Sunday that Texas Department of Public Safety operations are expected to โexpand in coming daysโ as part of immigration enforcement efforts.
Laredo man accused of smuggling 52 migrants; BCSO addresses heightened immigration concerns
Read full article: Laredo man accused of smuggling 52 migrants; BCSO addresses heightened immigration concernsA Laredo man accused of smuggling 52 migrants in three human smuggling cases has been arrested, the Bexar County Sheriffโs Office said on Saturday during a news conference.
Laredo man arrested in connection to human smuggling operations involving 52 migrants, BCSO says
Read full article: Laredo man arrested in connection to human smuggling operations involving 52 migrants, BCSO saysA Laredo man was arrested for allegedly being involved in human smuggling operations involving 52 migrants, according to the Bexar County Sheriffโs Office.
U.S. Senate investigation of migrant childโs death finds poor medical care at border protection facilities
Read full article: U.S. Senate investigation of migrant childโs death finds poor medical care at border protection facilitiesThe Senate Judiciary Committee launched its investigation following the 2023 death of an 8-year-old girl at a facility in Harlingen.
State lawmakers ask education agency for guidance on how Texas schools can respond to Trumpโs immigration plans
Read full article: State lawmakers ask education agency for guidance on how Texas schools can respond to Trumpโs immigration plansMore than two dozen Texas Democrats expressed concern about the elimination of a federal policy preventing immigration arrests at schools.
KSAT Q&A: Immigration attorney discusses impact of President Trumpโs executive order aiming immigration process
Read full article: KSAT Q&A: Immigration attorney discusses impact of President Trumpโs executive order aiming immigration processImmigration attorney Lance Curtright joined the KSAT Q&A on Wednesday with Steve Spriester and Myra Arthur to discuss the impact of President Donald Trumpโs executive order for immigration process, including what it means to have birthright citizenship.
โWeโre in the Wild Westโ: Legal experts warn of uncertainty over Trumpโs partial repeal of birthright citizenship
Read full article: โWeโre in the Wild Westโ: Legal experts warn of uncertainty over Trumpโs partial repeal of birthright citizenshipPresident Donald Trump followed through on a campaign promise Monday to move to remove the guarantee of citizenship for some children born on U.S. soil.
โKnow your rightsโ: ACLU of Texasโ flyers circulate amid deportation concerns
Read full article: โKnow your rightsโ: ACLU of Texasโ flyers circulate amid deportation concernsInformational flyers outlining the rights of undocumented immigrants have been circulating online, sparking discussions about legal protections for those approached by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) or police at their home or at work.
Migrants at Texas border in shock after Trump canceled their asylum appointments
Read full article: Migrants at Texas border in shock after Trump canceled their asylum appointmentsHours after Trumpโs inauguration, his administration canceled appointments allowing migrants to enter the U.S. to request asylum, leaving many of them stranded on the U.S.-Mexico border.
Immigration attorney warns of increased river crossings amid President Trumpโs border security plan
Read full article: Immigration attorney warns of increased river crossings amid President Trumpโs border security planEagle Pass residents are split on how they feel about President Donald Trumpโs path forward after he revoked an asylum-seeking mobile app on Inauguration Day.
Many Texas schools take โwait and seeโ approach to Trumpโs mass deportation plans
Read full article: Many Texas schools take โwait and seeโ approach to Trumpโs mass deportation plansSchools near the border say itโs hard to prepare for the unknown. Immigration advocates say they should help communities understand studentsโ rights.
Trump promised mass deportations. Hereโs one way they could quietly happen.
Read full article: Trump promised mass deportations. Hereโs one way they could quietly happen.The new administration could use the existing system of federal agents, local police and jails to funnel more people into the deportation pipeline.
Smuggling suspects arrested after 12 people found packed into SUV, BCSO says
Read full article: Smuggling suspects arrested after 12 people found packed into SUV, BCSO saysTwo people from South Texas have been arrested on smuggling charges. Sheriff's investigators they had 12 people crammed into an SUV.
Trump to tap Texas โborder czarโ to lead U.S. Border Patrol, report says
Read full article: Trump to tap Texas โborder czarโ to lead U.S. Border Patrol, report saysMike Banks, a former Border Patrol agent, has served in his current role as a special advisor to Gov. Greg Abbott since January 2023.
Governor Abbott fights to keep price tag of international border campaign private
Read full article: Governor Abbott fights to keep price tag of international border campaign privateA month after launching an international billboard campaign to deter illegal migrant crossings, Governor Greg Abbottโs office is trying to keep the projectโs cost a secret from taxpayers.
WATCH: Eagle Pass residents discuss immigration, economy on โYour Voice, South Texasโ
Read full article: WATCH: Eagle Pass residents discuss immigration, economy on โYour Voice, South TexasโKSAT visited Eagle Pass, a city at the epicenter of the immigration debate, for the tenth episode of โYour Voice, South Texas.โ
Texas Supreme Court to decide legal battle over El Paso migrant shelterโs future
Read full article: Texas Supreme Court to decide legal battle over El Paso migrant shelterโs futureJustices on Monday heard arguments from Annunciation House, which is fighting to stay open, and the Texas Attorney Generalโs office, which claims the shelterโs work with migrants violates state law.
Some Texas business leaders are apprehensive about Trumpโs pledged deportations
Read full article: Some Texas business leaders are apprehensive about Trumpโs pledged deportationsโWe wouldnโt surviveโ without undocumented workers, one South Texas produce business owner said. By one estimate, 8% of Texasโ workforce lacks legal status.
Here are the biggest stories from our data visuals team in 2024
Read full article: Here are the biggest stories from our data visuals team in 2024The Tribuneโs data journalists helped visualize everything from voter participation and extreme weather to gaps in the stateโs border wall. Here are some of the highlights.
Look back at some of the best Texas Tribune reads of 2024
Read full article: Look back at some of the best Texas Tribune reads of 2024Our journalists brought life to the experiences of everyday Texans, held powerful institutions accountable and surfaced stories that went beyond the daily news cycles.
What will happen to immigration in 2025? A San Antonio immigrant advocacy group has questions
Read full article: What will happen to immigration in 2025? A San Antonio immigrant advocacy group has questionsFred Schellenberg said his questions are starting to pile about how immigration policies could change as President-elect Donald Trump takes office in January.
Why were border wall materials put up for auction? Here's what you should know.
Read full article: Why were border wall materials put up for auction? Here's what you should know.Some Texas lawmakers including Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick slammed the Biden administration over the auction of wall materials. But the sale was directed by Congress โ and Texas has already bought some of it.
Cartels turn to social media to lure Americans into human smuggling as Texas enforces stricter laws
Read full article: Cartels turn to social media to lure Americans into human smuggling as Texas enforces stricter lawsThousands of people have been arrested under Texasโ human smuggling law. Now they face at least a decade in prison under sentencing guidelines that took effect this year.
Texasโ latest effort to deter migrants is a billboard campaign in Mexico, Central America
Read full article: Texasโ latest effort to deter migrants is a billboard campaign in Mexico, Central AmericaGov. Greg Abbott announced the new strategy, which will cost an estimated $100,000, during a press conference in Eagle Pass.
As landowners resist, Texasโ border wall is fragmented and built in remote areas
Read full article: As landowners resist, Texasโ border wall is fragmented and built in remote areasAt least a third of landowners approached by state officials have refused to let wall be built on their properties. Thatโs forced the state to largely build on ranchland in remote areas, or erect sections that are full of gaps.
Texas Republicans want voters to provide proof of citizenship. Arizonaโs law holds lessons.
Read full article: Texas Republicans want voters to provide proof of citizenship. Arizonaโs law holds lessons.A Votebeat analysis shows how such requirements risk disenfranchising key voter groups, including Native Americans and college students.
Gov. Greg Abbott announces more than $500 million in public safety grants
Read full article: Gov. Greg Abbott announces more than $500 million in public safety grantsThe grants will go to private and public sector recipients in Texas for a variety of public safety priorities, including securing the southern border.
Trumpโs promise of mass deportation throws undocumented Texans into fear, uncertainty
Read full article: Trumpโs promise of mass deportation throws undocumented Texans into fear, uncertaintyAs Republican Texas leaders show support for Trumpโs mass deportation plans, undocumented people โ some who have lived in America for decades โ are weighing their options amid mounting fears.
โThe best time to prepareโ: Migrant rights group warns undocumented Texans to plan for deportations
Read full article: โThe best time to prepareโ: Migrant rights group warns undocumented Texans to plan for deportationsGroups are urging the stateโs estimated 1.6 million undocumented migrants to prepare financially and make plans for their loved ones if theyโre detained.
WATCH: Republican and Democrat discuss Starr County election flip on โYour Voice, South Texasโ
Read full article: WATCH: Republican and Democrat discuss Starr County election flip on โYour Voice, South TexasโThe latest episode brings us to Starr County, a former Democratic stronghold that flipped from blue to red in the presidential election for the first time in over a century.
Federal judge blocks rule that would have given DACA recipients access to Affordable Care Act coverage
Read full article: Federal judge blocks rule that would have given DACA recipients access to Affordable Care Act coverageThe temporary injunction issued Monday would affect roughly 90,000 Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals recipients in Texas.
A 2006 study found undocumented immigrants contribute more than they cost Texas. The state hasnโt updated it since.
Read full article: A 2006 study found undocumented immigrants contribute more than they cost Texas. The state hasnโt updated it since.A comptrollerโs report found that deporting the estimated 1.4 million undocumented immigrants living in Texas in 2005 would have cost the state about $17.7 billion in gross domestic product.
Henry Cuellar pitched adding buoys in Rio Grande to deter migrants years ago
Read full article: Henry Cuellar pitched adding buoys in Rio Grande to deter migrants years agoThe congressman said he joined other Democrats in opposition to the use of the floating barriers and razor wire at Texasโ border because of the lack of permits.
Feds canโt destroy razor wire Texas installed near Eagle Pass, appeals court rules
Read full article: Feds canโt destroy razor wire Texas installed near Eagle Pass, appeals court rulesTexas Attorney General Ken Paxton had sued the Biden administration after Border Patrol agents had cut the razor wire.
Texas offers Trump administration more land and support for mass deportations
Read full article: Texas offers Trump administration more land and support for mass deportationsTwo events in the Rio Grande Valley on Tuesday made clear Texas officials will work with the Trump administration on immigration.

Texas General Land Office unveils proposed 1,402-acre site for immigrant detention, border wall
Read full article: Texas General Land Office unveils proposed 1,402-acre site for immigrant detention, border wallOfficials with the Texas General Land Office on Tuesday outlined plans for a 1,402-acre ranch it has offered to the incoming Donald Trump administration for housing undocumented immigrants before deportation.
Los hospitales en Texas ahora deben preguntarle a sus pacientes sobre su ciudadanรญa. No tienes que responder.
Read full article: Los hospitales en Texas ahora deben preguntarle a sus pacientes sobre su ciudadanรญa. No tienes que responder.El gobernador Greg Abbott quiere saber cuรกnto gastan los hospitales en el cuidado de inmigrantes indocumentados. Los hospitales no deben negar atenciรณn en ningรบn caso.
Texas hospitals are now required to ask for patientsโ citizenship. Hereโs what you should know.
Read full article: Texas hospitals are now required to ask for patientsโ citizenship. Hereโs what you should know.Gov. Greg Abbott wants to know how much hospitals spend caring for undocumented immigrants. Hospitals should not deny care based on how patients respond.